Op/Ed: Invoking Kabul Gurdwara attack to justify controversial CAA is totally unjustified

—This is in response to the write-up published in ‘The Tribune’ by K N Pandita on CAA with reference to the horrific terror strike at a historic Gurdwara- Guru’s place- in Afghanistan, killing 25 innocent Sikh worshippers. The author seems to justify the controversial citizenship amendment legislation in the context of this attack.

The writer ex-Director, Centre of Central Asian Studies, Kashmir University has asked those who are opposing the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) 2019 whether they would re-think their opposition to the act in the wake of Kabul gurdwara episode.

Cutting across the geographical and religious boundaries, the world from UN to OIC to western countries all in one voice has condemned the dastardly act carried out by the savages of the ISIS.

Let me make it clear at the very outset. The opposition is not against the Citizenship Act 1955 in itself but to the 2019 amendment under which Muslims have been omitted. The 2019 amendment provides for a path to citizenship for religiously persecuted minorities namely Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains, Parsis and Christians from Afghanistan, Bangladesh and Pakistan. Earlier the act had been amended in 1986, 1992, 2003, 2005 and 2015.

Secondly, the opposition to CAA got teeth, when the Home Minister Amit Shah speaking in the Parliament categorically stated that the next step of his government is National Register of Citizens (NRC).

The CAA/NRC posed a direct threat to the citizenship of Muslims of this country. The basic objection is how can the government pass an act or amend the earlier one targeting a particular religion. It goes against the spirit of the Constitution and democratic ethos. So much so, the United Nations human rights council chairperson Ms. Bachelet has termed it a discriminative law and the UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres raising his concern said that “There is a risk of statelessness” for two million people, mostly belonging to the Muslim community due to enforcement of CAA. The government of India or any non-state writer cannot run down the observations of these two top world diplomats.

Here, I would like to refer to an example of Malala Yousafzai resident of Swat Valley in north-west Pakistan. She wasn’t denied asylum by the United Kingdom just because she was a Muslim and came from an Islamic country- the core reason Indian government has been lending to justify exclusion of Muslims from the Act.

Quoting the gruesome killings of Sikhs in Kabul, the writer has tried to justify the CAA by saying that the CAA was enacted keeping in mind these realities. The Afghani Sikhs have been living in a fear of climate since last two decades. Most of them shifted to Delhi, handful to Peshawar in Pakistan and also few families went to Canada. Hundreds of Afghan Sikhs that are residing in Delhi are yet not given Indian citizenship despite several representations to successive governments by the DSGMC.

K.N.Pandita has posed a question to anti-CAA people that what if all these tens of thousands of Sikhs and Hindus approach the government for asylum on humanitarian grounds and choose to change their nationality? Knowingly or unknowingly, the writer has ignored the fact that the 2019 amendment clearly says that the person of above-said religions will be entitled for citizenship that has entered India on or before 31 December 2014. Here by making it clear that the Sikhs, who will come to India from Afghanistan now won’t be provided with the citizenship and that they would have to get settled with a refugee tag.

On threat to Sikhs in Afghanistan, I will quote Singapore-based author and filmmaker Amardeep Singh, who recently visited Afghanistan for his project to trace the footprints of Guru Nanak across nine countries. He said “Aren’t minorities singled out in the US? Doesn’t that happen in India too? Minorities everywhere will face situations where they will be singled out.

Strangely, the attack comes a day after the United States announced to cut its aid to Afghan government by $1 billion over frustrations that feuding political leaders could not reach an agreement and form a team to negotiate with the Taliban.

The Taliban who is gearing up to regain the seat of power in Kabul after the withdrawal of US forces, though denied their role in the attack on Gurdwara but stopped short of condemning it let alone promising the local Sikh population to protect them from any further attack. Had the Taliban done it in clear words, their gesture even if lip service would have boasted the morale of Sikhs, who are under constant threat and fear? Regrettably, the Taliban has maintained its silence so far. 

I remember  that when in August 2010 some miscreants in the name of ‘Jihad’ threatened valley Sikhs to leave Kashmir or join the struggle, Hurriyat Conference chairman SAR Geelani in a written statement stood by the beleaguered Sikh community and re-assured the local Sikhs that nobody would force them to leave the valley.

Sikhs have been made scapegoat in the larger game plan being played by major world players in Afghanistan. Yesterday’s massacre of Sikhs is fallout of power struggle going on in Afghanistan especially ever since US signed peace deal with Taliban at Doha on Feb 29, 2020. Since then, knives are out and hidden hands within and outside Afghanistan are hell bent to sabotage the deal.  

It’s testing time for Afghani Sikhs and their faith. Sikhs have historical Gurdwaras in Afghanistan. Guru Nanak Dev on his way back from Mecca travelled through Afghanistan. After July 2018 attack, this is second time that they have been targeted in a brutal way by ISIS militants.

There’s general understanding that the ISIS considers all non-Muslims and even Muslims including Taliban, who have refused to come under their self-proclaimed Khalifat as Kafirs. It was Daesh militants, who killed 32 Muslims belonging to Shia community on March 6 at a ceremony held to commemorate the 1995 slaying of Abdul Ali Mazari, the leader of Afghan’s ethnic Hazars. US officials have admitted that ISIS has been degraded because of US operations and also by Taliban assaults against them.

To further scare the Sikh population, it is being reported that ISIS have threatened them to leave the country within ten days. To avoid further casualties, Afghani Sikhs have started availing alternate options before them. At the time of worldwide lockdown due to corona virus outbreak, Afghan Sikhs have fewer options before them to shift to safer place. They look towards international community and Sikh Diaspora for their protection.

It is learnt that that the Modi dispensation is in touch with Sikh population in Kabul and the parleys are going on for their settlement in India. Back home, as the Narendra Modi Govt has utterly failed to crush the “people’s struggle” against CAA, there’s possibility that New Delhi might use the Afghani Sikh card to browbeat the anti-CAA people.

The SGPC and other Sikh organisations, Punjab based or abroad, should come forward to help these families in every possible ways including their settlement at a safer place of their choice. Which-ever country whether India or Pakistan permits Afghani Sikhs to get settled temporarily or permanently, should do so on humanitarian grounds keeping the politics aside.

Similar Articles


  1. Actually, again I request you to speak truth Kanwar Pal Singh ji! Let me begin by unequivocally say that I have no doubt in my mind that Modi and some of his ministers are bigots, no doubt. It is right to oppose a bigot but even if bigot is doing something right, he should be supported, scrutinized but supported. The truth is that the law CAA would be wrong but this was amended ONLY for non-muslims from Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan. Take Pakistan and Bangladesh for example, these were countries created for Muslims of India. Muslims that remain in India are Indians like anyone else in India. But Muslims that went to pakistan after dividing India, tell me why should they get any shot at Indian citizenship? How is that just request? As far as Afghanistan, it is clear that since 90s when Taliban took over minorities have been killed without mercy or asked to convert or pay jizya. I can personally provide proof of that. So Afghanistan was added to this list. Otherwise there is no other truth to this because even Adnan Sami is muslim and he is pakistani and he is Indian citizen. Today you feel great about Pakistan but it is same Pakistan that killed 2 million Hindus in 1971 + muslims and other minorities as well. HIndus in pakistan have to actually be treated like 2nd class citizens to the point where when you go to restaurant they have different dishes to use. Hindu and Sikh girls are abducted and converted and only ‘sort’ of justice I have seen is the case from Nanaka sahib because she was Ragi’s daughter, imagine the plight of not so famous Hindu and Sikh daughters. So while I dont want India to become like that and treat Muslims the same way, I do expect India to give these non-muslims from pakistan a citizenship.

    2nd issue here is there are already thousands of Hindus and Sikhs and other communities from these countries from India. THey have no papers so 1) even after studying they cant get any govt job or in company. You want them to suffer? 2) Not giving citizenship to people could also be security risk long term.

    I do not know about NRC so I wont say too much but what is so bad about counting rightful Indian citizens so they can get benefits they are providing? Yes, rightful Indian Muslims on eartern front may suffer because so many muslims from Bangladesh has come to US so there will be more scrutiny. But otherwise show you me how Muslims of India will not get citizenship. I challenge you to give some evidence.

    So I dont understand. I know you hate but I chose to see right even in people I hate. Modi Govt surely has many issues. I dont support them on almost everything. But he’s done good with this law. I like someone to show some reason. What you write here is wrong. Absolutely wrong.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Punjab ex-DGP Saini, suspended IG Umranangal held as accused in 2015 Behbal Kalan firing case

CHANDIGARH: Punjab former director general of police (DGP) Sumedh Saini and suspended inspector general of police (IGP) Paramraj Umranangal have been nominated as accused...

Stir to be intensified against farm bills, Punjab CM also to sit on dharna at Bhagat Singh’s village

:dateline:As the President of India, Ram Nath Kovind, has given nod to three farm bills which are anti-farmers in nature and affect Punjab badly,...

Indian Prez ignores protests, assents to ‘anti-farmer’bills, exclusion of Punjabi J&K official language

:dateline: Despite unprecedented protests going on in Indian Union especially in Punjab, Indian President Ram Nath Kovind today granted his assent to three anti-farmer...