Some scholars however have claimed that this move was unnecessary. These scholars have claimed that the move has come as a surprise as no one was expecting further reforms to the calendar. In addition, some scholars and intellectuals who were in past members of the Nanakshahi Calendar panel were not considered for this revision.
Prof. Jodh Singh of Punjab University, Patiala argued that there was a need to include mathematicians, environmentalists and other experts in the panel. He claimed that any additional changes to original Nanakshahi Calendar will not help unite the Panth.
In addition to Prof. Jodh Singh, Prof. Balwant Singh of Guru Nanak Dev University too has condemned the move. Prof. Balwant Singh was always a part of all original committees ever constituted to form or amend the Nanakshahi Calendar.
In contrast, the move to form panel comprising of Pal Singh Purewal (the original architect of the calendar) and Col. Surjeet Singh Nishan (one of the opponents) and scholars like Dr. Anurag Singh has been welcomed.