It was alleged that certain trustees in the gurudwara had submitted affidavits in court which barred Sikhs from wearing kirpans within the premises of the Gurdwara. �The matter was brought to the notice of Akal Takht Sahib which had formed a special committee to investigate the matter. �Based on the reports of the special committee, the 5 Singh Sahibs had given an ultimatum to the Rochester Gurudwara Committee to clarify the matter.
The trustees of the Gurudwara later retracted their stance and allowed kirpans less than 6 inches long. �This stance was however not accepted by Sri Akal Takhat Sahib and ultimately, the trustees had to revert the Gurdwara clauses. �The ban was ultimately lifted by�Judge Mathew A. Rosenbaum.
The court decision however does not resolve the matter, as mediation still needs to occur between the current and previous management parties of the Gurdwara. �The dispute over the kirpan arose after a lawsuit involving the trustees of the Gurdwara and local Amritdhari sangat. �It is believed that the trustees had placed a ban on kirpans to keep amritdhari sangat from attending the Gurdwara. �Aside from imposing a ban on the kirpan, one of the five articles of the Sikh faith, Santokh Badesha, the head trustee, had ridiculed the kirpan and the kesh.